are railroad ties toxic

Project Fab

4 min read

·

19-03-2025

1

0

Share

Are Railroad Ties Toxic? Understanding the Risks of Creosote-Treated Wood

Railroad ties, those sturdy, dark-brown beams that support the tracks of railways, are a common sight across the globe. Their enduring strength and resistance to decay have made them a popular material for landscaping projects, retaining walls, and even furniture. However, the longevity of these ties comes at a cost: many are treated with creosote, a complex mixture of chemicals derived from coal tar, that poses significant health and environmental risks. This article delves into the toxicity of railroad ties, exploring the composition of creosote, the associated health hazards, environmental concerns, and safer alternatives for landscaping and other projects.

The Composition of Creosote and its Toxicity:

Creosote, historically the most common preservative used for railroad ties, is a complex cocktail of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), which are known carcinogens. These PAHs are semi-volatile, meaning they can evaporate into the air, leach into the soil and groundwater, and transfer to living organisms through contact. The exact composition of creosote varies depending on the source of the coal tar and the manufacturing process, but it typically contains hundreds of different chemicals, many of which are toxic.

Some of the most concerning components of creosote include:

• Benzo[a]pyrene (BaP): A potent carcinogen classified as a Group 1 human carcinogen by the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC). Exposure to BaP can increase the risk of lung cancer, skin cancer, and other cancers.
• Chrysene: Another PAH that is suspected of being carcinogenic and mutagenic.
• Phenols: These compounds can cause skin irritation, respiratory problems, and other health issues.
• Polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins (PCDDs) and Polychlorinated dibenzofurans (PCDFs): Extremely toxic compounds that are highly persistent in the environment and bioaccumulate in the food chain.

The concentration of these toxic compounds in creosote-treated railroad ties varies, depending on the age of the tie and the environmental conditions. Older ties tend to have higher concentrations of leachable PAHs due to weathering and degradation of the wood.

Health Hazards Associated with Creosote-Treated Railroad Ties:

Exposure to creosote can occur through various routes:

• Dermal Contact: Direct skin contact with creosote-treated wood can cause skin irritation, allergic reactions, and potentially more serious health problems with prolonged exposure.
• Inhalation: Creosote dust and vapors can be inhaled, leading to respiratory irritation, coughing, and potentially more serious lung diseases. Chronic exposure has been linked to an increased risk of lung cancer.
• Ingestion: Ingestion of creosote is rare, but it can cause serious gastrointestinal problems.
• Groundwater Contamination: Leaching of creosote from railroad ties into groundwater can contaminate drinking water sources, posing a significant risk to human health.

The severity of health effects depends on the level and duration of exposure, as well as individual susceptibility. Children and pregnant women are particularly vulnerable to the effects of creosote exposure.

Environmental Concerns:

The use of creosote-treated railroad ties presents several environmental concerns:

• Soil Contamination: Creosote leaching into the soil contaminates the surrounding ecosystem, harming soil microorganisms and potentially affecting plant growth.
• Groundwater Contamination: As mentioned earlier, creosote can leach into groundwater, contaminating drinking water supplies and harming aquatic life.
• Air Pollution: The volatilization of creosote from railroad ties contributes to air pollution, particularly in areas with a high density of these ties.
• Bioaccumulation: PAHs and other toxic compounds in creosote can bioaccumulate in the food chain, meaning that their concentrations increase as they move up the food chain, potentially reaching harmful levels in animals and humans.

Safer Alternatives for Landscaping and Other Projects:

Given the significant health and environmental risks associated with creosote-treated railroad ties, there are several safer alternatives available for landscaping and other projects:

• Pressure-Treated Lumber: Lumber treated with chromated copper arsenate (CCA) was once a common alternative, but its use has been largely phased out due to arsenic concerns. Currently, most pressure-treated lumber uses copper azole preservatives, which are considered less toxic than creosote and CCA.
• Recycled Plastic Lumber: This eco-friendly option is durable, resistant to decay, and requires no chemical treatments.
• Concrete: Concrete is a strong, durable material suitable for retaining walls and other landscaping projects.
• Untreated Wood: For projects where durability is less critical, untreated wood can be a suitable option.

Identifying Creosote-Treated Ties:

Identifying creosote-treated railroad ties is relatively straightforward. They typically have a dark, almost black color, a distinctive creosote odor, and a visibly oily or greasy surface. However, some ties may appear less dark over time due to weathering.

Disposal and Remediation:

Proper disposal of creosote-treated railroad ties is crucial to minimizing environmental risks. Many municipalities have specific regulations regarding the disposal of these ties. Improper disposal, such as burning or landfilling without proper containment, can lead to widespread contamination. Remediation of contaminated soil and groundwater is a complex and costly process that may involve excavation, bioremediation, or other specialized techniques.

Conclusion:

While railroad ties offer durability and strength, their creosote treatment poses significant health and environmental hazards. The presence of PAHs and other toxic compounds necessitates caution in their handling and use. For landscaping and other projects, safer alternatives are readily available, offering comparable durability and longevity without the risks associated with creosote-treated wood. Understanding the risks and choosing safer alternatives is crucial for protecting human health and the environment. Always consult with local regulations regarding the handling, use, and disposal of railroad ties. If you suspect creosote contamination, contact your local environmental agency for guidance and assistance.